Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Is that her brother?

Hey everyone  just here to say a perdition maybe Elliot Hill is Heidi's own brother. On page 173 Elliot Mr.Hill's son had a temper tantrum and I also think that he has mental problems and that  got me questioning if Elliot was Heidi's brother I was thinking this because Heidi's mother has tantrums and mental problems so maybe Heidi's mother gave birth to Elliot  and Heidi's mother might have gave Elliot  her mental problems and her temper tantrums. That is why I think Elliot is Heidi's brother, because Heidi's mother could have given birth to both of them. What do you think?

4 comments:

  1. well i havent read that (i know i screwd)but that sounds right and i cant wait to read it

    ReplyDelete
  2. That might be right. It is a good guess but when I read this blog I kept on thinking that don't all mental people have tempertantrums. It just might be one thing to think about.-Sarah W

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Sarah, Owen, and Emily,

    Great questions about the Stereotypes we have of people will mental disabilities? Maybe why this book is important to read. I think the Elliot plays and important role in the book. What do you think? This is a powerful idea to consider. I think we will be coming back to this point.

    Mr. B

    Emily Great Quote

    ReplyDelete
  4. i agree that in someway he is related to her, but this time i think it may be her father or.... a friend that so B it hd while she was there. i think that the word may have been some sort of inside joke or,an intimate word thatnoone else knew. i am not sure but i cant waittill tomorrow when we get to read the rest!

    ReplyDelete